30 April 2009 @ 01:15 pm
I still need an angry icon  
Does it make me a really, really bad person that I get really pissed when someone deletes their fic/journal?

And I mean, 'ARG! THAT IS SO FREAKING ANNOYING!' and then the really awful bit: 'WHO THE HELL DO YOU THINK YOU ARE!?/HOW DARE YOU!?'

I do realise that having a sense of entitlement over a story that belongs to someone else is completely irrational and kind of dickheaded, but that's just the reaction I get.

Now, I realise people often/usually have very good reasons for talking their fics offline. Abuse, C&Ds, publishing, RL pressure, but there are so many better ways of handling things than just vanishing. And I also feel that hello, this is the INTERNET, if you've already put something out there, it's out there, you can't stop the signal, dudes!

When someone like Maya took her fanfic offline, she gave months of notice and put everything into a PDF that people could download to their own machines. She knew that someone would probably host it, but the point was that she couldn't, due to getting original work published, and that the number of new readers would be greatly reduced. She didn't want to cut her old readers who had loved those stories for years, she just had to take them offline. Managed! With grace!

So, I dunno, when I see people just up and vanish, it really ticks me off, because for one thing, their fics are NOT lost, it is highly likely that even if the internet doesn't store them any more, someone will have it on their HD and it will eventually be hosted via some storyfinders page somewhere. So, I dunno, if you've got issues, I wish people would either follow Maya's example, or just, I dunno, freeze all comments everywhere on their journal and slap up a 'I'm leaving. Goodbye' post.

In the end, of course it's any writer's right to leave the internet or remove their fic, I just wish people would realise that, a) it's kind of futile, and b) it's really hurtful to the people who have become emotionally connected to those stories over the years.

Anyway, this wasn't pointed at anyone in particular, I was just reminded of it this morning as I trawled through the internet archive to try and grab all the fic of an author I really like who has gone bye-bye.

Now I have to stop procrastinating and face up to the, 'You know I love you despite your freaky sexuality, right?' text I got from my Dad this morning. Oh joy. :/
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] desolate-noir.livejournal.com on April 30th, 2009 05:02 am (UTC)
Ditto, I feel like that sometimes but you said it better than I probably could.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
[identity profile] prairie-grass.livejournal.com on April 30th, 2009 01:40 pm (UTC)
I felt kind of embarrassed posting about this, because in a lot of ways I feel like this reaction is over the top, but I still wanted to say something because MAN it annoys me, even if I have no right to feel annoyed.

Or something. *shrugs*
(Reply) (Parent) (Link)
[identity profile] mimei.livejournal.com on May 1st, 2009 09:08 am (UTC)
i don't know if i've come across anyone who thinks deleting their fic off the net thinks this'll make it disappear. i mean, in a sense it does; it removes it from fandom outsiders and lurkers. but i've always seen putting something online as a choice you make knowing it's going to be there.

at the same time, i can understand why people might want to just disappear. comments almost completely drop off a few days after you post something (at least in my fandoms) & lj doesn't provide a way to view hits so even if logically you know that every so often someone discovers your fic, it can feel pretty pointless to leave this ticking time bomb someone who knows you could discover just sitting there. it's just...hard to quantify.

the one that annoys me most is flocked fic journals. it's just so against the whole givingness of a gift economy.

'despite.' grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.
(Reply) (Link)