29 April 2009 @ 12:28 pm
so what's up with that, then?  
Okay so, I love gender-swap fic, very very much, but it's been annoying me today how in the Supernatural fandom people are so quick to be all, 'Oh, I'm a girl now, I'll never be able to hunt/fight/do anything and/or especially take down Sam.' Now, I know chicks don't have as much testosterone as guys, and as such it's harder for us to build up muscle and in general we're smaller and less strong than guys, but for fuck's sake, people, fighting is not ALL about size and muscle-strength.

I've been doing Kung Fu now for like, 8 weeks, and our instructor is TINY. He's smaller than me, and I can guarantee you that he can take down the biggest guy in our class in about two seconds flat. My style of Kung Fu is all about getting inside someone's space, and that's actually easier when you're small, in a lot of ways. Now, I could readily believe that Sam and Dean don't actually know any Kung Fu, but things they probably do know, like Jujitsu or Thai Kickboxing all have ways a small person can fight and beat a bigger person. It's not all about who has the most muscles, it's about speed, weight placement, angles and balance and knowing the right moves to use against the appropriate opponent.

So, I could understand the boys needing to change some of their guns, and I can understand a lot of time needing to be spent re-training to use the different weight, size and speed the changed person has, but if you're going to write a gender-swap, please don't assume that either of the guys would be incapable at hunting and/or taking down the other guy. Fighting has weight-divisions in contests to make it an even playing field, not because it's impossible for little people to take down big people.

Now, I'm sick in bed today, so if anyone wants to make me feel better by writing me a fic with girl!Dean taking down Sam who's all sure Dean won't have a chance in his cute little girl body, I'd totally be okay with that. *beams*

Edit: I'm waiting for my screen-writing lecturer to get back to me with the assignment he was supposed to give out, and in the mean time I've written, 1200~ words of the next part of Pack Your Bags. And come to a very firm chapter-end, so, as there is a whole lot of stuff that's supposed to come after that, it seems the story has turned into a three-part-er. Part2 clocks in at about 5,700~ and I expect 3 to be about 3-5k? The whole 'verse will probably be somewhere around 13k. I'm not really sure if I should post this part nowish or if I should wait till it's all done. :/ I'm inclined to wait, I think. Posting unfinished fics doesn't appeal to me as much as it once did... -_-;

Anyway, I'm off to edit DMT_07 now, since the Harry Potter fans may send glow-worms to kill me in the night if I ignore my WiPs to work on Supernatural fic any more than I already have. ^____^;;;;
 
 
Current Mood: annoyed
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] mimei.livejournal.com on April 29th, 2009 02:19 am (UTC)
your media product fandom, it fails you. ;)

get well soon bbcakes!!

Edited 2009-04-29 02:19 am (UTC)
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
[identity profile] prairie-grass.livejournal.com on April 29th, 2009 03:45 am (UTC)
Just a little? I was reading something this morning that was like, 'Dean looked more feminine, but hadn't lost all that much muscle tone' and I thought, if I worked out as much as Jensen has to to make his body look like that, as well as having had the combat training Dean has had, I could kick the ass of someone TWICE my size. Hell, after a few more months of Kung Fu I could probably already do that. (unless they also had martial arts training, in which case I would need Dean's version) SO! Fandom! Get with the program!

I hope to! This is more a defensive day in bed, I feel crap, but not HUGELY crap, so I'm hoping if I'm nice to myself today I can get away with being only vaguely sick.

(This is me spamming your inbox, by the way. I think I will go find something ELSE to reply to!)
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)
[identity profile] mimei.livejournal.com on April 29th, 2009 03:49 am (UTC)
the thing that gets me about Spn is - well, put it simply - truck drivers. they basically live live truck drivers. you never see them jogging, let alone running, in gyms, or exercising at all. they eat terribly. and sure young men can keep up with that lifestyle a while but...i mean, what exactly aren't they showing us? early morning sparring sessions...?

anyway i agree wholeheartedly with the salient point. i think it's just another case of women being their own worst enemy. way too common in fandom. and life.

*tucks you in* rest!

(you know i love the spam.)
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)
[identity profile] prairie-grass.livejournal.com on April 29th, 2009 03:55 am (UTC)
YES! So very much yes! I think the fandom agrees that there are invisible running and sparring sessions. Fuck, now I REALLY want to write a massive workingout!fic @_@ Although I don't know how Sam is supposed to have THAT much muscle without some serious equipment. Maybe he bench-presses Dean or something. @_____________@

Ahh, so painfully true. We are all so grossly indoctrinated. Which was why I brought it up, because it honestly never occurred to me so clearly until today, probably just because of what I've been learning in Kung Fu.

that works out well then!
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Link)
[identity profile] mimei.livejournal.com on April 29th, 2009 04:11 am (UTC)
uh-huh! bit too invisible imho. they need a sekreet hide-out workout place. like batman. i don't know how Sam is allowed to have so much muscle! scary buff! clearly their physiques are a result of strenuous bedtime activities.

grossly indoctrinated and also fuelled by poorly thought-out self-interest! it's a man's world. i love how learning new things makes you connect the dots in different ways! go the page-inator!
(Reply) (Parent) (Link)
[identity profile] foolazuli.livejournal.com on April 29th, 2009 06:25 am (UTC)
Look at you all kung fu-y!!!
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
[identity profile] prairie-grass.livejournal.com on April 29th, 2009 06:30 am (UTC)
Oh yeah, I'm totally the master. *snorts* But you agree, right, a chick could totally take down a big guy with the right moves?

DUDE I was just about to email you. ARE YOU DONE?! I've been all, EEEEH! FOO THESIS and a little confused as to the done-ness. There seem to be several stages of donnage.

I WANT TO GIVE YOU A HUG.

Failing that, lets set up a skype-date, yes?
(Reply) (Parent) (Link)